Hybrid governance for Terra Nova physical communities: off-chain sociocratic circles + on-chain treasury and reputation.
1. Philosophy
Blockchain governance excels at allocating capital and recording decisions immutably. It fails at resolving conflicts, reading body language, and growing trust.
Physical communities excel at human connection, shared labor, and cultural continuity. They fail at transparent accounting, global coordination, and censorship-resistant record-keeping.
The L5 DAO framework combines both: sociocracy for daily decisions, on-chain tools for money and memory.
"Votes are for money. Circles are for people. Never confuse the two."
2. Off-Chain: Sociocratic Circles
2.1 Structure
Every L5 community organizes itself into circles — self-governing teams with a clear domain. Each circle:
- Has a defined purpose (why it exists)
- Has a clear domain (what it decides)
- Uses consent-based decision-making (not consensus)
- Elects a facilitator and a secretary
- Sends a link (representative) to the parent circle
General Circle (all Guardians + elected long-stay members)
├── Operations Circle
│ ├── Agriculture Sub-circle
│ ├── Hospitality Sub-circle
│ └── Infrastructure Sub-circle
├── Finance Circle
│ └── Treasury Sub-circle
├── Community Circle
│ ├── Conflict Care Sub-circle
│ └── Culture & Ritual Sub-circle
└── Knowledge Circle
├── Seed Library Sub-circle
└── Education Sub-circle
2.2 Consent-Based Decision-Making
Not consensus. Consent means: "I have no reasoned objection to this proposal."
Process:
- Presentation — proposal owner explains the proposal (5 min)
- Clarifying questions — anyone can ask (10 min)
- Reactions — everyone shares feelings/reactions (1 min each)
- Amend & integrate — proposal owner refines (5 min)
- Objection round — anyone with a reasoned objection speaks (15 min)
- Resolve objections — amend proposal or accept objection as valid concern
- Consent check — facilitator asks: "Does anyone have a reasoned objection?"
- Record — secretary records decision, rationale, and timestamp
Valid objection criteria:
- Does this proposal endanger community safety?
- Does this proposal violate our shared agreements?
- Does this proposal exceed the circle's domain?
- Is there a better way to achieve the same aim?
Invalid objections:
- "I don't like it" (personal preference without reason)
- "We tried this before and it failed" (past experience is not a principle)
- "I have a better idea" (propose it separately)
2.3 Meeting Rhythms
| Circle | Frequency | Duration | Attendance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Operations Circle | Weekly | 60 min | All operational Guardians |
| Finance Circle | Bi-weekly | 90 min | Finance Guardian + elected members |
| Community Circle | Monthly | 120 min | All Guardians + long-stay members |
| Knowledge Circle | Monthly | 90 min | Knowledge Guardian + elected members |
| General Circle | Quarterly | 180 min | All Guardians + elected long-stay members |
3. On-Chain: ZION DAO
3.1 Treasury Multisig
Every L5 community maintains a multisig treasury on the ZION blockchain:
Community Treasury (3-of-5 multisig)
├── Signer 1: Finance Guardian (warm wallet, hardware)
├── Signer 2: Community Guardian (warm wallet, hardware)
├── Signer 3: Operations Guardian (warm wallet, hardware)
├── Signer 4: External trustee (cold wallet, steel backup)
└── Signer 5: ZION Foundation representative (cold wallet, legal backup)
Thresholds:
- 2-of-3 for daily operations wallet (sub-account)
- 3-of-5 for treasury reserve (cold storage)
- 4-of-5 for constitutional changes ( Guardianship removal, legal entity change)
3.2 Spending Tiers
| Tier | Amount | Decision path | On-chain? | Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Micro | < 100 EUR | Operations Circle lead | No (off-chain accounting) | Immediate |
| Small | 100–500 EUR | Parent circle consent | Yes (recorded, not executed) | 24h |
| Medium | 500–5,000 EUR | Finance Circle → General Circle | Yes (multisig 2-of-3) | 48h |
| Large | 5,000–20,000 EUR | General Circle consent → multisig | Yes (multisig 3-of-5) | 7 days |
| Extraordinary | > 20,000 EUR | General Circle + on-chain community vote | Yes (quadratic voting, 14 days) | 14 days |
3.3 Proposal Format
Every on-chain proposal must include:
{
"proposal_id": "genesis-2029-03-015",
"community": "genesis-garden",
"title": "Purchase 10 kWp solar expansion",
"author": "operations-guardian-01",
"circle": "Operations Circle",
"tier": "large",
"amount_eur": 12000,
"amount_zion": "TBD at execution time",
"recipient": "supplier-wallet-or-escrow",
"rationale": "Current 5 kWp system insufficient for Phase 2. Expansion allows...",
"circle_consent_date": "2029-03-01",
"circle_consent_proof": "hash-of-meeting-minutes",
"timeline": "2029-04-01 to 2029-05-15",
"milestones": [
{"date": "2029-04-15", "deliverable": "Panels delivered", "release_pct": 50},
{"date": "2029-05-15", "deliverable": "Installation complete", "release_pct": 50}
],
"kpis": [
"Daily energy production > 40 kWh",
"Guest capacity increased by 10"
],
"risk_mitigation": "Supplier vetted. Backup supplier identified. Insurance covers transport.",
"review_date": "2029-06-01"
}
3.4 Reputation and Roles
Guardians earn on-chain reputation through participation:
| Action | Reputation Points | Cap per period |
|---|---|---|
| Attend circle meeting (with proof) | 10 | Weekly |
| Submit proposal (approved) | 50 | Monthly |
| Submit proposal (rejected, but valid) | 10 | Monthly |
| Mentor new Guardian | 100 | Per mentorship |
| Resolve conflict (verified) | 150 | Per case |
| Node uptime > 99% | 200 | Quarterly |
| Humanitarian contribution (verified) | Variable | Annual |
Reputation unlocks:
- 500 points: Can propose without sponsorship
- 1,000 points: Can serve as multisig signer
- 2,000 points: Can represent community at L5 network council
- 5,000 points: Can propose constitutional changes
3.5 Slashing Conditions
Guardians can lose reputation or be removed for:
| Offense | Consequence | Appeals |
|---|---|---|
| Unauthorized treasury spend | Reputation reset, removal from multisig | 14-day appeal to General Circle |
| Node downtime > 7 days without notice | -500 reputation, warning | 7-day appeal to Tech Circle |
| Conflict of interest (undisclosed) | -300 reputation, recusal required | Community Circle mediation |
| Harassment / abuse | Immediate suspension, 30-day investigation | External arbitration (TBD) |
| False proposal data | Proposal rejected, -200 reputation | 7-day appeal to Finance Circle |
4. Hybrid Decision Examples
Example 1: Buying a Tractor
Off-chain:
- Operations Circle discusses need, researches models, gets quotes
- Agriculture Sub-circle tests tractor at supplier
- Operations Circle reaches consent: "Buy tractor X from supplier Y for EUR 8,000"
On-chain:
- Finance Guardian submits proposal to L2 DAO with circle consent proof
- 48h review period; no objections from other Guardians
- 3-of-5 multisig executes payment to escrow
- Milestone 1 (delivery): 50% released
- Milestone 2 (acceptance): 50% released
- KPI review after 3 months: fuel efficiency, hours used, maintenance cost
Example 2: Admitting a New Guardian
Off-chain:
- Applicant completes 30-day probatory stay
- Community Circle interviews applicant
- General Circle reaches consent: "Admit [Name] as Farm Guardian"
On-chain:
- Community Guardian submits membership proposal
- 14-day review: any Guardian can raise objection (with reason)
- If no objection: automatic on-chain record + reputation assignment
- If objection: General Circle resolves within 7 days; if unresolved, escalates to L5 Network Council
Example 3: Emergency Spend (Volcanic Evacuation)
Off-chain:
- Emergency declared by any Guardian
- Immediate action: 2-of-3 operations wallet spends up to EUR 2,000
- Retroactive consent sought from General Circle within 48h
On-chain:
- Emergency spend recorded as "retroactive proposal"
- General Circle reviews: if legitimate, ratified; if not, Guardian responsible for repayment
5. L5 Network Council
When 3+ L5 communities exist, they form a Network Council — a meta-governance body for cross-community decisions.
5.1 Domains
- Shared protocol standards (mesh frequency, seed exchange format)
- Dispute resolution between communities
- Allocation of L5 global humanitarian fund
- Admission / expulsion of communities from network
5.2 Representation
Each community sends 1 elected delegate to the Network Council. Decisions require consent of 2/3 of represented communities.
5.3 On-Chain
Network Council decisions are recorded on-chain as multi-community proposals:
- Each delegate signs with their community multisig key
- Threshold: 2/3 of community signatures
- Execution: via L2 DAO smart contract (when implemented)
6. Tools and Infrastructure
6.1 Off-Chain Tools
| Tool | Purpose | Open Source? |
|---|---|---|
| Sociocracy 3.0 patterns | Meeting formats, consent process | Yes (sociocracy30.org) |
| Loomio | Async decision support | Yes (loomio.org) |
| CryptPad | Encrypted collaborative documents | Yes (cryptpad.fr) |
| Signal / Matrix | Secure group chat | Yes (Signal: clients; Matrix: protocol) |
| Physical minutes book | Legal backup, culture | N/A (paper, signed) |
6.2 On-Chain Tools
| Tool | Purpose | Status |
|---|---|---|
| ZION core node | Block validation, RPC, wallet | ✅ Implemented |
| L2 DAO (Axum) | Proposals, voting, treasury tracking | ✅ Implemented |
| Multisig wallet | Threshold spending | ✅ Implemented (script-based) |
| Reputation registry | Guardian points, history | 🔵 Planned (2028) |
| Quadratic voting | Large / constitutional decisions | ✅ Live (pilot round) |
| Escrow contracts | Milestone-based payments | 🔵 Planned (2029) |
7. Constitutional Principles
These principles cannot be changed without 4-of-5 multisig + 14-day community vote:
- Land sovereignty: The community's physical land is held in trust for future generations. It cannot be sold for private profit.
- Open source: All community tools, methods, and documentation are shared freely.
- Non-discrimination: No one is excluded based on origin, belief, gender, or economic status. (Behavioral standards apply.)
- Environmental responsibility: Every decision must consider its impact on soil, water, and biodiversity.
- Protocol alignment: The community remains aligned with ZION consensus rules and the 5% humanitarian tithe.
"Democracy is two wolves and a sheep voting on dinner. Sociocracy is the sheep saying 'I have a reasoned objection.' And the wolves listening."
V3/L5/GOVERNANCE · Community DAO Framework · 2026